Weewar Forum

**Tygerdave** · This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 07/05/2013 15:10:55

http://weewartimes.com/2010/02/25/2010-weewar-times-map-contest-finalists-selected/
Here are your finalists:

1. WeeWar Times for Pete’s Sake by Vagus

2. WeeWar Times Wetlands by Nature_God

3. Weewar Times Square by Stirlingxa

Your votes determine the winner of 1 year of Pro! Comments are welcome. Please keep in mind that we're looking for a good tournament map, and be sure to favorite all the maps you like even if you can only vote for 1!

Poll is open for 7 days

**Warmaker**

You listed StirlingXA twice on the links, yo.

And I'm not campaigning for one person, but one of these maps is seriously solid.

**Tygerdave**

thanks - fixed

**RockyDog**

I think you have the wrong Vagus map in the finals. What happened to this one

its so wicked it took stirling to convince vagus and me that it is indeed fair.

**Tygerdave**

Glad you like it, be sure to favorite it! That one has gotten a lot of compliments.

**Shulgin**

RockyDog wrote:I think you have the wrong Vagus map in the finals. What happened to this one

its so wicked it took stirling to convince vagus and me that it is indeed fair.

i'm with rockydog here. i tested this map a lot with vagus and i loved the game play on it, which is quite different from most of the other maps out there. in my opinion this map deserves to be a finalist. having said that, the chosen maps do look intriguing as well

**Darkbee**

Does anyone else get an internal server error when they try to click the links to the 3 different maps?

**The_Shrike** · This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 26/02/2010 14:18:27

Works for me from here and the WeeWar Times post

How did you know my last name was Else? Hacker!

**Darkbee**

Anyone wrote:Works for me from here and the WeeWar Times post

How did you know my last name was Else? Hacker!

Don't worry, your email address and Paypal account details are perfectly safe with me!

**Somar96**

I actually think choosing Stirling as a finalist wasn't a good choice as he doesn't need a year of pro - he doesn't play anymore. From the 2 left, I like the Wetlands more. And I certainly don't know why Vagus's map is winning the poll with such a high result.

**Tygerdave**

I'm playing a game with him right now, and no one NEEDS a year of pro.

It's a contest not charity, vote for the best map.

**Nature_God** · This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 26/02/2010 16:33:13

Wow! I cannot believe my map made it into the final 3

- who ever picked it as one of the finalist, thank you very much

I would just like to add that my map is not actually perfect in design. 8,2 should have a water hex instead of a plain hex so that it is the same as the opposite side. It does not make much difference at all, but just thought I would mention. - my excuse (which i just made up) is that I did not want the map to be prefect as the imperfection represents human nature and that we all make mistakes, specially when playing weewar

**Vagus**

Interesting...

You picked the map I never won on in testing. Red or Blue, it didn't matter. Everyone I played crushed me.

**McMonster**

sad that all the finalists are small relatively geometric maps. there could have been some variety here. tournaments happen on all kinds of maps - from Stirlings Europe to Aruba, so that really doesn't explain it.

that said, i look forward to testing these and voting; i admit my bias for real world and historical over geometric maps - which is also an admission that i am griping because i would have liked to have seen my entry selected, of course; this contest is a super-great idea and i think it's tygerdave who deserves a free year of pro

if only he'd play me in a rated game, i might gift it to him

**Darkbee**

Part of the criteria for the maps were to be small and playable over a short period of time. Perhaps Tyger, you might like to attach the criteria to the original post to help users further judge the maps.

WeeWar Times for Pete’s Sake by Vagus	50%	[ 14 ]
WeeWar Times Wetlands by Nature_God	32%	[ 9 ]
Weewar Times Square by Stirlingxa	18%	[ 5 ]
Total Votes : 28

26/02/2010 02:36:46 Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Tygerdave Tank Offline	http://weewartimes.com/2010/02/25/2010-weewar-times-map-contest-finalists-selected/ Here are your finalists: 1. WeeWar Times for Pete’s Sake by Vagus 2. WeeWar Times Wetlands by Nature_God 3. Weewar Times Square by Stirlingxa Your votes determine the winner of 1 year of Pro! Comments are welcome. Please keep in mind that we're looking for a good tournament map, and be sure to favorite all the maps you like even if you can only vote for 1! Poll is open for 7 days This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 07/05/2013 15:10:55
26/02/2010 02:51:07 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Warmaker Berserker Offline	You listed StirlingXA twice on the links, yo. And I'm not campaigning for one person, but one of these maps is seriously solid.
26/02/2010 02:52:07 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Tygerdave Tank Offline	thanks - fixed
26/02/2010 11:30:47 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
RockyDog Berserker Offline	I think you have the wrong Vagus map in the finals. What happened to this one its so wicked it took stirling to convince vagus and me that it is indeed fair.
26/02/2010 12:04:15 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Tygerdave Tank Offline	Glad you like it, be sure to favorite it! That one has gotten a lot of compliments.
26/02/2010 13:29:14 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Shulgin Tank Offline	RockyDog wrote:I think you have the wrong Vagus map in the finals. What happened to this one its so wicked it took stirling to convince vagus and me that it is indeed fair. i'm with rockydog here. i tested this map a lot with vagus and i loved the game play on it, which is quite different from most of the other maps out there. in my opinion this map deserves to be a finalist. having said that, the chosen maps do look intriguing as well
26/02/2010 13:56:56 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Darkbee Berserker Offline	Does anyone else get an internal server error when they try to click the links to the 3 different maps?
26/02/2010 14:16:54 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
The_Shrike Trooper Offline	Works for me from here and the WeeWar Times post How did you know my last name was Else? Hacker! This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 26/02/2010 14:18:27
26/02/2010 14:37:27 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Darkbee Berserker Offline	Anyone wrote:Works for me from here and the WeeWar Times post How did you know my last name was Else? Hacker! Don't worry, your email address and Paypal account details are perfectly safe with me!
26/02/2010 15:20:50 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Somar96 Tank Offline	I actually think choosing Stirling as a finalist wasn't a good choice as he doesn't need a year of pro - he doesn't play anymore. From the 2 left, I like the Wetlands more. And I certainly don't know why Vagus's map is winning the poll with such a high result.
26/02/2010 15:25:15 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Tygerdave Tank Offline	I'm playing a game with him right now, and no one NEEDS a year of pro. It's a contest not charity, vote for the best map.
26/02/2010 16:28:16 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Nature_God Tank Offline	Wow! I cannot believe my map made it into the final 3 - who ever picked it as one of the finalist, thank you very much I would just like to add that my map is not actually perfect in design. 8,2 should have a water hex instead of a plain hex so that it is the same as the opposite side. It does not make much difference at all, but just thought I would mention. - my excuse (which i just made up) is that I did not want the map to be prefect as the imperfection represents human nature and that we all make mistakes, specially when playing weewar This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 26/02/2010 16:33:13
26/02/2010 19:33:33 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Vagus Raider Offline	Interesting... You picked the map I never won on in testing. Red or Blue, it didn't matter. Everyone I played crushed me.
26/02/2010 20:46:06 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
McMonster Tank Offline	sad that all the finalists are small relatively geometric maps. there could have been some variety here. tournaments happen on all kinds of maps - from Stirlings Europe to Aruba, so that really doesn't explain it. that said, i look forward to testing these and voting; i admit my bias for real world and historical over geometric maps - which is also an admission that i am griping because i would have liked to have seen my entry selected, of course; this contest is a super-great idea and i think it's tygerdave who deserves a free year of pro if only he'd play me in a rated game, i might gift it to him
26/02/2010 21:18:01 Re:Pick the winner of the 2010 WeeWar Times Map Contest!
Darkbee Berserker Offline	Part of the criteria for the maps were to be small and playable over a short period of time. Perhaps Tyger, you might like to attach the criteria to the original post to help users further judge the maps.

Poll results: Which Map Wins The WeeWar Times 2010 Contest